Annuar call on AFL to review rules after Immigration II exit

KUALA LUMPUR: Prominent football figure Tan Sri Annuar Musa has urged the Amateur Football League (AFL) to review its regulations on mid-season withdrawals.

He said that wiping out match results unfairly penalises clubs that had legitimately earned points.

In a Facebook post, the former Kelantan FA (KAFA) president criticised the current mechanism, which expunges results involving a withdrawing team and strips rival clubs of points earned in those matches.

His remarks follow the withdrawal of Immigration II from the A1 Semi-Pro League campaign after eight fixtures, prompting the AFL to declare all matches involving the team null and void.

The decision has affected six clubs, whose points and goal tallies from those fixtures were removed from the standings.

Five teams had recorded victories over Immigration II – Kelantan City (4-0), Selangor II (3-1), Armed Forces (3-0), Negri Sembilan II (2-1) and AAK Unisel (2-1).

Kedah FA also lost a point after its 1-1 draw against Immigration II in the opening round was expunged.

Annuar argued that competition regulations should not penalise clubs that had committed resources and competed in good faith.

“AFL should review the rule of deducting points from teams that previously won or drew against a side that withdraws,” Annuar wrote.

“It is not fair to punish other teams that have spent money, earned points, and succeeded in their matches against the withdrawing side.”

He stressed that any punishment should be directed at the team responsible for the withdrawal, rather than having consequences for other clubs.

“Punishment should be limited to the withdrawing team, not other teams that have legitimately earned points from their matches. Punishing other teams retrospectively is unjustified,” he wrote.

As an alternative, Annuar proposed awarding default victories to teams scheduled to face the withdrawing side, instead of removing previous results.

“Awarding a win to the teams scheduled to play is much fairer,” he said.

On Friday, AFL chairman Datuk Yusoff Mahadi announced that Immigration II had been fined RM50,000 and banned from all AFL-sanctioned competitions for two seasons following its withdrawal.

The A1 League will continue with the remaining 13 teams, with the standings reshaped following the expungement of Immigration II’s results.