GEORGE TOWN: Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow has rebuked Bagan member of parliament Lim Guan Eng for repeatedly alleging unethical conduct in the Perak-Penang bulk water deal.
Chow, who chairs PBA Holdings Bhd (PBAHB) and Perbadanan Bekalan Air Pulau Pinang (PBAPP), said it was regrettable that Lim continued to repeat the allegations despite repeated explanations about the Bulk Water Supply Agreement (BWSA).
In a statement, Chow questioned why securing 40 years of water supply for residents, industries, investors and future generations could be considered unethical.
He said the agreement had received approval from all PBAPP board members and secured 98 per cent shareholder support at PBAHB’s extraordinary general meeting (EGM) on Nov 12.
Addressing concerns over the board’s decision, Chow said the views and professionalism of five PBAHB independent directors had been recorded and respected during the meeting, which passed the agreement by a majority vote of seven to five.
“Their objections were solely focused on specific payment terms, which have already been addressed through clauses in the agreement,” he said.
Lim had recently accused Chow of acting unethically by dismissing concerns over the state’s RM8.4 billion water deal with Perak.
He said Chow had disrespected the financial judgement and professionalism of five independent directors of PBAHB who objected to the agreement’s terms.
Chow also dismissed Lim’s allegation that PBAPP would be forced to pay RM210 million annually for 40 years without receiving a single drop of water, describing the portrayal as misleading and unethical.
He said PBAPP was not required to make any payment to Perak before water supply implementation began, and any disbursement remained subject to approval by the National Water Services Commission.
Under the arrangement, Penang would gain access to substantial water infrastructure capacity without bearing the full construction costs and early-stage development risks.
Chow added that PBAPP held contractual rights to take action, including invoking termination mechanisms, if unrectified breaches occurred.
“This means Penang is not locked into paying until 2072 as claimed,” he said.

Leave a Comment