Collaboration with Bersatu no cure to PH’s Malay dilemma

KUALA LUMPUR: Pakatan Harapan’s best bet to shore up Malay support ahead of the next general election may be limited cooperation with Bersatu, although even that is unlikely to deliver significant gains, analysts say.

“Many voters have made up their mind to not vote for PH even if PH manages the economy well or lowers living costs,” said Sunway University political scientist Professor Wong Chin Huat.

Wong said although the swing voters — PH’s core support base — had shrunk, the coalition still needed to manage the economy and cost of living well as the leading coalition in government.

He said the recent Melaka election offered PH its best possible strategy, where it and Bersatu avoided contesting against each other in certain seats.

The move was aimed at preventing vote splitting against Barisan Nasional and Perikatan Nasional candidates, but proved ineffective in stopping the “Blue Wave”, which swept all Malay-majority seats in last week’s Melaka polls.

Wong said a full alliance with Bersatu would be counterproductive for PH, as their past conflicts could risk further alienating the coalition’s support base.

“The best way is the Malacca model, no contest in some constituencies and contest in some others.”

However, Wong said even this “best way” might not significantly help either PH or Bersatu.

“The high transferability of votes between BN and PN means many seats would become uncompetitive,” he said.

Wong said low non-Malay voter turnout, if repeated in the next general election, could also hurt PH.

“The Chinese turnout in Malacca was estimated to be 20 percentage points lower than the Malays. While this wasn’t enough to hurt PH in Malacca, it might lose many seats in GE16.”

At the same time, Wong said DAP, the party with the most seats in PH, would remain a convenient target for the coalition’s rivals.

He said many DAP leaders needed to improve their “Malay cultural literacy”, citing the backlash against Kota Melaka MP Khoo Poay Tiong’s comments on the enforcement of shop closures during Friday prayers in Terengganu.

However, he said this did not change the fact that DAP remained an easy target.

[[nid:1582937]]

“Even DAP leaders who are close to Malays and understand Malay cultures well like Steven Sim and Howard Lee were not spared from attacks.”

Nusantara Academy of Strategic Research senior fellow Professor Dr Azmi Hassan also said a PH-Bersatu tie-up would do little to improve their electoral fortunes.

“Bersatu just cannot deliver on the Malay votes which PH really needs.

“The three state polls show that Malay voters have no qualms voting either for a BN or PN candidate.”

Azmi said DAP and the actions of some of its leaders had also helped fuel cooperation between BN and PN.

“So I don’t think an alliance between PH-Bersatu will make a difference, especially as Melaka has demonstrated. Bersatu cannot steal the votes from BN-PN.

“In fact, Bersama did much better in terms of stealing votes compared to Bersatu.”

Azmi said PH should instead try to exploit issues that could strain cooperation between BN and PN, particularly over seat allocations.

“This will be the main issue between BN-PN. PH should look at offering BN better seat allocations. Between BN and PH, there will be a minimum overlap.”