PUTRAJAYA: Takaful operators can claim tax deductions for ordinary financing expenses under the Income Tax Act, the Court of Appeal has ruled.
A three-member bench led by Datuk Azhahari Kamal Ramli allowed Etiqa Family Takaful Bhd’s appeal to deduct RM62.3 million in financing costs incurred over five years.
The ruling overturned decisions by the Special Commissioners of Income Tax (SCIT) and the High Court, which had disallowed the deductions for the assessment years 2014 to 2018.
The other members of the bench were Datuk Hayatul Akmal Abdul Aziz and Datuk Ong Chee Kwan.
Ong, who wrote the judgment, said Section 60AA of the Income Tax Act, which specifically governs takaful businesses, did not exclude Section 33(1), which allows deductions for expenses incurred in generating income.
He said the two provisions served different purposes and could operate together.
“Section 60AA is not a self-contained code which switches off the general provisions. Parliament has said in terms that they continue to apply,” he said in his written grounds of judgment.
The dispute arose after Etiqa issued a Tier 2 subordinated bond structured as a sukuk in 2014 to raise additional capital to meet Bank Negara Malaysia’s minimum capital adequacy requirements.
Between 2014 and 2018, the company made profit payments totalling RM62,301,699 to bond subscribers and claimed them as tax deductions.
However, the Inland Revenue Board (IRB) disallowed the deductions, saying the payments were not among the expenses specifically permitted under Section 60AA(9)(b).
The SCIT upheld the IRB’s decision, which was later affirmed by the High Court.
In overturning the decisions, Ong said the High Court had erred in treating Section 60AA as the exclusive provision governing deductions claimed by takaful operators.
The Court of Appeal found that Etiqa’s sukuk profit payments were ordinary financing expenses rather than costs arising from the specific structure of takaful operations.
Ong said the IRB had also failed to explain why takaful operators should be denied deductions for financing expenses when conventional insurers and banks could claim similar deductions.
Etiqa was represented by lawyers Datuk S. Saravana Kumar and Tan Jass Key, while the IRB was represented by Ashrina Ramzan Ali, Wan Khairuddin Wan Montil, Siti Aisyah Yusoff Md Nasir and Nik Amyrah Syarinie Mohd Dusuki.
