Court overturns acquittal, jails 64-year-old man for rape

PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal today ordered a senior citizen to be jailed13 years and given four strokes of the rotan after allowing the prosecution’s appeal against his acquittal for raping a 19-year-old girl in Rompin, Pahang, four years ago.

A three-member bench chaired by Datuk Mohamed Zaini Mazlan, sitting with Datuk Ahmad Shahir Mohd Salleh and Datuk Dean Wayne Daly, unanimously allowed the prosecution’s appeal against the acquittal of Nasir Sharif, 64, the respondent.

The bench reinstated the conviction and original sentence imposed by the Kuantan Sessions Court under Section 376(1) of the Penal Code.

However, the bench dismissed the prosecution’s cross-appeal to enhance the sentence, ruling that 13 years’ imprisonment and four strokes fell within a reasonable exercise of judicial discretion.

The court also ordered a committal warrant to be issued immediately against Nasir, a village worker, for him to begin serving his sentence today.

In a brief judgment read out by Ahmad Shahir, the court held that the Kuantan High Court had erred in acquitting and discharging Nasir on the grounds that the prosecution had failed to prove penetration beyond reasonable doubt.

“Defence counsel argued that the victim did not see the penetration and merely inferred that the object was a penis, while claiming the victim’s narrative was implausible as she was unaware her clothes were removed while she was asleep,” he said.

Rejecting the submission, Ahmad Shahir said the victim’s testimony that she felt the penetration occur constituted direct evidence.

“Only the anatomical identity required an inference, and that inference was highly limited based on the fact that the respondent was lying on top of the victim with both hands beside SP2’s shoulders and his trousers down to his ankles,” he said.

He said the bench also accepted the legal position that penetration does not necessarily cause injury or tearing, and that for the offence of rape, slight penetration is sufficient.

“In our view, neutral medical evidence does not create a reasonable doubt,” he said.

Ahmad Shahir said the Sessions Court judge had found the victim to be a credible witness after observing her demeanour during the trial, whereas the High Court made no finding that she lacked credibility.

“That finding was also supported by her complaint to the fourth prosecution witness (SP4) on the same day while in a state of fear, a police report lodged that same night, and a fresh abrasion which, according to the medical officer, occurred within 24 hours.

“It is a settled principle of law that witness credibility lies strictly within the province of the trial judge, and we are satisfied that the victim’s testimony is credible and safe to rely upon,” he said.

According to the charge, Nasir was accused of raping a 19-year-old girl in a room at a house in Rompin, Pahang, at 3pm on May 12, 2022.

Based on the facts of the case, the victim, who was sleeping on her back in her room, woke up upon feeling pain in her private parts and found the accused on top of her before pushing him away and reprimanding him.