Court overturns adoption order involving foreign national

KUALA LUMPUR: The High Court in Penang has allowed the National Registration Department (NRD) to challenge a court order directing it to issue a birth certificate to an adopted Chinese citizen.

Judicial commissioner Suraiya Mustafa Kamal made the ruling after allowing NRD to become a party to an adoption appeal filed by a Malaysian man and his Chinese national wife, who sought to adopt the wife’s niece.

She ruled that the earlier court order, dated March 17, was null and void on the grounds of illegality or lack of jurisdiction as it required NRD to act contrary to the Adoption Act and the Births and Deaths Registration Act.

Suraiya said the court retained the power to set aside the order even though it had been finalised, particularly when it contravened statutory requirements.

The case stemmed from an adoption application filed by the couple to adopt the wife’s niece, who was born in Liaoning, China, on April 23, 2007.

The girl had been living with the couple in Penang since 2017 following the separation of her biological parents.

On Oct 17 last year, the George Town Sessions Court dismissed the couple’s adoption application on the grounds that the girl did not possess a Malaysian birth certificate and that her ordinary residence had not been sufficiently established.

However, on March 17, High Court judge Dr Choong Yeow Choy allowed their appeal and granted the adoption order.

Choong ruled that foreign-born children without Malaysian birth certificates could still be adopted, provided the legal requirements were met and their welfare was protected.

The order also directed NRD to register the adoption and issue a birth certificate reflecting the girl’s Chinese nationality and birthplace.

However, NRD challenged the order, arguing that it could not be implemented as the girl was not a Malaysian citizen and did not possess a birth certificate issued under the Births and Deaths Registration Act.

NRD filed an application on July 28 seeking to be added as a party to the proceedings and to set aside the March 17 order.

The couple raised a preliminary objection, arguing that NRD had no legal standing to challenge the order as it was not a party to the original proceedings.

They also argued that the High Court had no authority to revisit its earlier decision because the order had already been finalised.

However, Suraiya rejected both arguments.

She said NRD was directly affected by the order as it was the statutory authority responsible for issuing birth certificates.

“It is important that the applicant be named as a party from the beginning of the court’s process as only the applicant is vested with the authority to perform and execute the March 17 order,” she said in her written grounds of judgment dated Nov 16.

She also rejected the couple’s argument that NRD’s application was filed out of time, ruling that the delay did not prevent the department from challenging an unlawful order.

“The principle of justice dictates that justice should be done not only for the appellants or the child, who is not a Malaysian citizen, but justice should also be extended to all other affected parties,” she said.

Lawyer Koay Ee Teng represented the couple, while federal counsel Nordiyanasari Omar appeared for NRD.

Koay said the case is now pending appeal at the Court of Appeal.