Court reserves decision on Tan Kok Ping’s appeal on defamation award to Penang CM

PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal today reserved its decision on businessman Tan Sri Tan Kok Ping’s appeal against a High Court ruling ordering him to pay RM350,000 in damages to Penang Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow for defamation.

A three-member panel comprising Justices Datuk Azizul Azmi Adnan, Datuk Aliza Sulaiman and Datuk Seri Latifah Mohd Tahar reserved its decision after hearing submissions from Tan’s counsel, Datuk K. Kirubakaran, and Chow’s counsel, K. Simon Murali.

On Dec 3, 2024, the Penang High Court ordered Tan to pay RM350,000 in damages after finding that remarks he made at a press conference on Oct 18, 2023, were defamatory.

The remarks, made in Mandarin, were translated as “incompetent”, “ignorant” and “shameless”.

High Court judge Datuk Quay Chew Soon found that the remarks, which were published by six Chinese-language newspapers and an English-language daily, had seriously damaged Chow’s reputation.

In his submissions before the Court of Appeal today, Kirubakaran argued that the High Court judge had erred in law and fact in finding the three words defamatory.

He said Chow had merely stated the Malay translations of the three words as their alleged defamatory meanings in his statement of claim.

However, in his witness statement, Chow had expanded on the meanings, attributing to the remarks a more injurious defamatory meaning than that originally pleaded.

Kirubakaran argued that Chow could not rely on a more defamatory meaning than the one set out in his statement of claim, as doing so would be prejudicial to Tan. He added that Chow should be bound by his pleadings.

He further submitted that the High Court judge had erred in accepting Chow’s self-serving explanation of the impugned remarks.

“There was an absence of evidence from members of the community or third parties or experts on Chinese language as to the meaning and effect of the impugned statement on Chow,” he said.

In response, Simon Murali urged the Court of Appeal to dismiss Tan’s appeal, submitting that the High Court’s judgment was beyond reproach and contained no appealable errors.

He further submitted that the High Court judge had correctly considered the relevant facts and applied the applicable legal principles in finding that Tan was motivated by malice in making the defamatory remarks.

Simon Murali said there was no appealable error in the High Court judge’s finding that Tan’s defence of justification was unsustainable.

He added that the High Court had also rightly rejected Tan’s defences of qualified privilege and fair comment.

Chow filed the defamation suit against Tan, who is the life honorary president of the Penang Chinese Chamber of Commerce, in January 2024 over remarks made by Tan concerning the sale of state land in Batu Kawan.

At today’s Court of Appeal proceedings, Chow was represented by lawyers Kek Boon Wei, Lee Wen Qian, Fatimatuz Zahra Suhaimi and S. Sharanya.