Dual role leaves question of who polices the league

KUALA LUMPUR: Nearly two months after Datuk Ab Ghani Hassan won the FA of Malaysia (FAM) presidency and said he would leave the Malaysian Football League (MFL), the question hanging over local football is: who polices the league when FAM’s president still runs both?

That governance gap has been thrust into focus during Harimau Malaya’s November tour, with Malaysia losing to China 2-0 on Saturday and a clash with Yemen on Tuesday without Johor Darul Ta’zim (JDT) regulars omitted for club duties and six Selangor players ruled out injured after a Nov 8 FA Cup semi-final.

While FAM remains under month-to-month FIFA and AFC monitoring following its eligibility scandal, critics warn that leaving one man atop both the national regulator and the league operator blurs accountability at a moment that demands clear separation of powers.

The contrast with Ghani’s predecessors is sharp. In March 2018, Tunku Ismail Sultan Ibrahim left FAM to lead MFL.

“I cannot hold two positions,” he reportedly said, with clubs later electing then FAM chief Tan Sri Hamidin Amin in Sept 2019, before he stepped aside after 23 months.

“I am not power-hungry and now is the right time to step back,” Hamidin said at the 57th FAM Congress in March 2021, before resigning in August 2021 to install Ab Ghani specifically to separate regulator from league operator.

Since defeating Datuk Seri Shahril Mokhtar on Sept 17, Ab Ghani has yet to relinquish the MFL presidency, despite saying he “cannot focus on two positions”, indicating a successor had been identified and hoping to complete the handover within “about a month”.

He was still chairing MFL’s board meeting on Nov 3.

Ghani has defended the pace, maintaining he stayed to keep league operations smooth and reportedly said on Oct 19 that the selection “cannot be done hastily or haphazardly”.

Football critic Datuk Dr Pekan Ramli said the continued overlap undermines administrative credibility and leaves Harimau Malaya exposed when club interests collide with the international calendar.

“He already promised to let go, and when he does not, despite saying there are things to consider and no candidate, it creates a conflict of interest because policy and implementation are not aligned,” Pekan said.

“FAM should enforce a separation of powers quickly. With both titles, there will be problems with checks and balances between the needs of the clubs and the national team – we can see it now with Harimau Malaya.”

Sports lawyer Nik Erman Nik Roseli said no written rule bars holding both presidencies, yet the overlap clashes with international ethical guardrails.

“I agree there are no clearly defined rules prohibiting the FAM president from also holding the MFL presidency, but ethics means understanding that not everything needs to be in black and white. Certain matters are understood from the principle and intention of existing written law,” he told Timesport.

“Article 19 of the FIFA Code of Ethics requires a person not to perform their duties where there is a conflict, and there is a clear conflict between the governing body and the body managing the league. Even if he refrains from making a decision and remains in the room, his mere presence could result in a decision favourable to MFL.”

Nik Erman noted that Article 33(2)(xvii)(c) also allocates FAM’s second vice-president seat ex officio to the MFL chief, leaving an already downsized congress short of one seat.

“What if FAM wanted to take action against MFL, would he punish himself? Is there really no one else in Malaysia that we need one person to hold two highly demanding positions?” he said.

Separately, MFL’s Nov 3 board reshuffle, chaired by Ghani, seated three FAM representatives, including vice-president Datuk Seri Rosmadi Ismail, alongside former FAM deputy president Datuk S. Sivasundaram as an independent representative and directors from JDT, Kuching City and Penang.

“It is time for MFL to polish its appointment criteria because there are things to be questioned,” Dr Pekan said.

“Why and how are these independent representatives appointed?”


Discover more from UM LEGACY PRESS LTD

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.