Govt must explain criteria behind KLSCAH premium cut from RM4.67mil to RM1,000

KUALA LUMPUR: The government should disclose the valuation basis and approval criteria behind the reduction of the Kuala Lumpur and Selangor Chinese Assembly Hall’s (KLSCAH) land premium from RM4.67 million to just RM1,000 for a 99-year lease renewal.

Former Malaysian Armed Forces Future Force Secretariat director Major General (Rtd) Datuk Dr Mohd Radzi Abdul Hamid said an explanation was necessary to ensure transparency, fairness and good governance in the decision.

He said such a substantial reduction was difficult to justify, adding that the explanations given so far had failed to convince the public, particularly the Malay community.

“The initial premium of RM4.67 million must have been based on a valuation. If that figure was correct, how could it suddenly become RM1,000? If RM1,000 is the correct amount, what was the basis of the earlier valuation?

“The heritage building argument is rather puzzling. KLSCAH has been gazetted as a heritage building since 2007. Why, after almost 19 years, has this status now become one of the reasons for such a substantial reduction in the land premium?” he said in a Facebook post.

Radzi said he understood that the reclassification of the land from commercial to institutional use could result in a lower valuation, as explained by Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department (Federal Territories) Hannah Yeoh.

However, he said the government should clarify whether the reclassification could reasonably justify a reduction of almost 100 per cent, given that institutionally-zoned land in Kuala Lumpur still held value.

He also questioned whether Malay and Indian organisations, veterans’ associations, charitable bodies and owners of other heritage buildings could enjoy similar reductions.

“If they can, announce the same policy for everyone. There should be no perception of selective treatment,” he said.

Radzi said he was not opposed to KLSCAH or efforts to preserve Chinese community heritage, adding that the community’s historical contributions deserved recognition.

However, he said respect for heritage should not mean that the government’s financial decisions were beyond scrutiny.

“The government should disclose the basis of the original and revised valuations, as well as the criteria for approving the premium reduction.

“Do not turn this into a racial issue. This is about transparency, fairness and good governance,” he said.

Yesterday, Yeoh explained that the land premium was reduced from an estimated RM4.67 million to RM1,000 following the conversion of its land status from commercial to institutional use.

She said the conversion meant the land no longer carried commercial value and could not be developed for condominiums or shopping malls.

On Nov 14, the government approved the renewal of KLSCAH’s land lease for 99 years, with the premium set at a nominal RM1,000, compared with the previous estimated premium of about RM4.67 million.

The Federal Territories Land Committee had approved the surrender and re-alienation of the land for institutional use on Sept 14.

The official approval letter, dated Oct 1, stipulated a land premium of RM1,000, while the total amount payable, based on the official land notice, was RM5,011. This included the first year’s land rent and administrative charges.

The annual land rent was set at RM3,151.

The decision followed Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim’s commitment to give special consideration to efforts to preserve the historic building after visiting the assembly hall during Chinese New Year celebrations on Feb 17.