High Court: Developers cannot escape liability for recurring defects

SHAH ALAM: Property developers cannot escape liability for construction defects even after the defect liability period (DLP) has expired, the High Court has ruled.

Judge Sumathi Murugiah made the ruling after finding that Astana Modal (M) Sdn Bhd had failed to effectively rectify recurring water leaks and related damage in luxury homes at D’Island Residence in Puchong.

She said developers remained responsible for poor workmanship despite having carried out repairs, particularly when defects persisted or recurred.

“Astana’s earlier rectification works and the expiry of the DLP do not provide a complete defence where the water leakage remained or recurred because the repairs were ineffective.

“I therefore find that the plaintiffs have proven that Astana breached its obligation to construct and deliver the affected properties in a good and workmanlike manner,” she said in her grounds of judgment delivered yesterday.

The ruling followed two lawsuits against Astana involving 69 purchasers of 41 semi-detached and super-linked houses, as well as two other purchasers of a double-storey house in the same development.

The purchasers claimed that their properties had numerous defects, including cracks, water leaks, staining, uneven finishes and alleged structural deficiencies.

Although Astana had carried out repairs on several occasions, some defects persisted or recurred, prompting the purchasers to take legal action.

Sumathi said the recurring defects were concerning, given that the properties had been marketed as luxury homes and sold at high prices.

“Given that the properties were marketed as luxury homes and sold for high prices, it is impossible to ignore the recurring occurrence of defects.

“Defects may ordinarily arise during the DLP and be remedied by the developer.

“However, the defects in the present case were not isolated complaints confined to the DLP.

“Some of them recurred despite Astana’s previous attempts to rectify them and continued to appear even after the DLP had expired,” she said.

She said Astana’s own structural expert had also accepted that damage to plaster ceilings caused by water leaks was uncommon in a five-year-old building.

Sumathi said developers could not rely on an “as is where is” clause in a sale and purchase agreement to avoid liability for hidden defects or poor workmanship.

However, she dismissed the purchasers’ claims that their homes were structurally unsafe or unfit for occupation.

She said they had failed to provide sufficiently reliable technical evidence to prove that the concrete used in the properties did not meet the required Grade C25 specification.

Grade C25 refers to concrete designed to withstand a compressive strength of 25 megapascals (MPa), a specification commonly used for structural components such as beams, columns and floor slabs.

Sumathi also dismissed their claims seeking to invalidate the Certificates of Completion and Compliance (CCCs) issued for the properties.

The court ordered Astana to pay the reasonable costs of rectifying recurring water leaks and the resulting damage to the affected properties.

The amount is to be calculated based on rectification quotations submitted during the trial, before the court order is filed.

The court also awarded the purchasers RM35,000 in legal costs.

Other claims, including refunds of the property purchase prices, expert fees, separate negligence damages, general damages for distress, aggravated damages and exemplary damages, were dismissed.


Discover more from UM LEGACY PRESS LTD

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.