Ismail’s resignation not effective until Ruler’s consent, says constitutional expert

KUALA LUMPUR: Datuk Ismail Lasim remains Negri Sembilan Menteri Besar until his resignation is consented to by the Yang di-Pertuan Besar of Negri Sembilan Tuanku Muhriz Tuanku Munawir, in accordance with the state’s constitutional convention.

Constitutional expert Prof Dr Nik Ahmad Kamal Nik Mahmod said the position should be viewed in the context of Negri Sembilan’s constitutional practices, which require the Ruler’s consent for the menteri besar’s resignation.

He said although the Negri Sembilan Constitution did not expressly state that royal consent was required for the resignation, the state’s established convention must be taken into account when determining the status of the office.

“An examination of Article 38 of the state constitution shows that it covers the appointment of the menteri besar and the circumstances in which the office-holder must resign after losing majority support in the state legislative assembly.

“However, it does not specifically state whether the Yang di-Pertuan Besar’s consent is also required when the menteri besar resigns voluntarily.

“In this context, we have to consider Negri Sembilan’s constitutional convention, which requires the menteri besar’s resignation to be consented to by the Yang di-Pertuan Besar,” he said.

Nik Ahmad Kamal said Ismail would continue to hold office and carry out his duties until royal consent was granted, if such consent was a prerequisite for the resignation to take effect.

“If consent is a requirement, he remains the menteri besar until it is granted.

“However, if consent is not a requirement, the resignation would already have taken effect. Nevertheless, based on the palace’s official statement, we must accept the practice observed in Negri Sembilan,” he said.

He said the next development would depend on the Yang di-Pertuan Besar’s decision on the resignation.

“Once consent is granted, the resignation takes effect and Ismail will no longer hold the post of menteri besar,” he said.

It was reported yesterday that Ismail had arrived at Istana Hinggap at 5pm for an audience with Tuanku Muhriz.

However, neither the palace nor Ismail has issued an official statement on the outcome of the meeting.

Earlier, the Negri Sembilan Palace, in a statement by Royal Comptroller Datuk Azizi Mohamad Ali, said the menteri besar’s resignation would only take effect after receiving Tuanku Muhriz’s consent, in accordance with the state constitution.

The palace had also said it had yet to verify the authenticity of the resignation letter attributed to Ismail.