Court: Insurer cannot deny claim over policy held in deceased owner’s name

PUTRAJAYA: Insurance companies cannot deny compensation to road accident victims on the grounds that a vehicle’s insurance policy was renewed in the name of its deceased registered owner, the Court of Appeal has ruled.

A three-member bench, chaired by Datuk Mohamed Zaini Mazlan, unanimously dismissed Liberty Insurance Bhd’s appeal to invalidate the policy, ruling that the insurer could not rely on defects in the policy to avoid compensating an accident victim.

Other members of the bench were Datuk Leonard David Shim and Datuk Aliza Sulaiman.

The case involved motorcyclist Mohamad Munir A. Hasan, who was paralysed from the waist down after his motorcycle collided with a lorry emerging from a side road in February 2023.

The lorry’s registered owner, Koay Kuan Liong, had died in July 2018, nearly five years before the accident.

However, the lorry’s insurance policy was renewed in his name for the period between Sept 1, 2022 and Aug 31, 2023.

Munir filed a suit against the driver and the deceased registered owner at the Butterworth Sessions Court in November 2023.

Liberty Insurance then filed an originating summons at the Penang High Court seeking a declaration that the insurance policy was void and unenforceable.

The company argued that the policy was invalid because the registered owner had died before its renewal and therefore lacked the legal capacity and insurable interest to enter into an insurance contract.

It also claimed that the failure to disclose the owner’s death amounted to a breach of the duty of utmost good faith.

However, the High Court dismissed the application on June 19 last year, prompting Liberty Insurance to appeal.

Shim, who wrote the grounds of judgment, said compulsory third-party motor insurance was intended to protect innocent road accident victims regardless of the contractual arrangements between insurers and policyholders.

He said Section 96(1) of the Road Transport Act required insurers to satisfy judgments involving liabilities covered by compulsory third-party insurance, even if they were entitled to avoid or cancel the policy.

“The mere fact that the registered owner has died and the policy continued in his name did not, without more, render the compulsory third-party insurance unenforceable against the innocent third-party.

“There is no evidence of fraud or collusion in obtaining the insurance policy,” he said in the written grounds of judgment issued recently.

Shim said the statutory rights of innocent accident victims could not be denied on grounds such as non-disclosure of material facts, breach of utmost good faith, lack of contractual capacity or absence of insurable interest.

“A third-party claimant is not a party to the contract of insurance and does not derive his right of recovery from the contract itself.

“His right arises pursuant to the statutory provisions in the RTA enacted for the protection of innocent third parties to recover,” he said.

The court also found that Liberty Insurance had failed to carry out proper checks before issuing the policy in the deceased owner’s name.

Shim said the company’s insurance agent did not ask the deceased’s son, Koay Ghee Seong, whether he was the named policyholder or enquired about his father.

The agent also failed to check Ghee Seong’s identity card despite the insurance proposal form being unsigned and incomplete.

The court held that Liberty Insurance was deemed to have waived compliance with the duty of disclosure under Schedule 9 of the Financial Services Act.

The court also ordered Liberty Insurance to pay RM40,000 in costs to Munir.