GEORGE TOWN: Penang Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow has been accused of acting unethically by dismissing concerns over the state’s RM8.4 billion water deal with Perak.
Bagan MP Lim Guan Eng said Chow had disrespected the financial judgement and professionalism of five independent directors of PBA Holdings Bhd (PBAH) who objected to the agreement’s terms.
In a statement today, Lim said: “It is unethical for Chow to disrespect the professionalism and sound financial logic of five independent directors of PBAH.”
He said Chow had described his objections to the capacity charges as “irresponsible”, dismissing written concerns raised by the five directors at PBAH’s extraordinary general meeting on Nov 12.
The dispute centres on Perbadanan Bekalan Air Pulau Pinang’s (PBAPP) obligation to pay Perak RM210 million annually for 40 years, totalling RM8.4 billion, regardless of whether treated water is supplied.
Under the Northern Perak Water Supply Scheme (NPWSS), PBAPP must pay the fixed capacity charge even if Perak supplies less than the contracted minimum of 300 million litres of treated water daily or delivers no water at all, Lim said.
The scheme, scheduled to begin on March 31, 2032, carries RM8.4 billion in capacity charges and a further RM16.2 billion in supply charges, depending on the volume of water delivered.
Lim said he supported sourcing water from Perak as an alternative to Sungai Muda and had initiated the project during his tenure as chief minister. He said his objection was to the financial terms, not the search for an alternative water source.
He also disputed Chow’s claim that terminating the agreement over a failure to supply water would end PBAPP’s payment obligations.
Chow had earlier rebuked Lim for misleading the public over the Perak-Penang Bulk Water Supply Agreement (BWSA), saying explanations had already been given to state assemblymen and shareholders.
Lim’s latest criticism followed Chow’s remarks, with Lim accusing the chief minister of dismissing the directors’ concerns rather than addressing the agreement’s financial terms.
Lim said the state government had refused to table the full agreement in the Penang State Legislative Assembly, citing non-disclosure clauses, and called on Chow to explain the RM24.6 billion commitment.
