Kepong bak kut teh assault: Trio fail in bid for DNAA

KUALA LUMPUR: Three men charged with assaulting a businessman at a bak kut teh restaurant in Kepong failed in their bid to secure a discharge not amounting to an acquittal (DNAA) from the Sessions Court over delays in the prosecution’s disclosure of key documents to the defence.

The application was filed by lawyers Muhamad Firdaus Jumaludin and S. Narasimham, who argued that the prosecution’s failure to furnish crucial documents had placed their clients at a disadvantage.

Firdaus, who represented the first and second accused, carpenter Wong Weng Luen, 49, and technician Lai Kae Bin, 33, told the court that he had yet to receive the forensic report, despite the case coming up for its fourth mention today.

Narasimham, who represented the third accused, memorial centre worker Wan Ken Fei, 30, supported the application.

Firdaus said the prosecution’s repeated requests for extensions to furnish the report had prejudiced the accused, particularly as their bail applications had been unsuccessful.

He said Wong and Wan had been denied bail, while Lai remained in custody after failing to raise the RM20,000 bail sum granted to him.

“The defence also needs to be provided with the complete closed-circuit television (CCTV) recording for us to scrutinise before deciding whether any representation should be submitted,” he said.

Narasimham said it was unfair for the accused to remain in custody while crucial documents were still outstanding.

He questioned the delay in obtaining the forensic report and whether the investigating officer (IO) had made sufficient efforts to secure it.

“It should not be difficult to obtain the document.

“I have been instructed by my clients to submit representations once the medical and forensic reports are obtained, as both are important for the representations as well as the trial,” he said.

Deputy public prosecutor Adiba Iman Hassan, however, defended the IO, saying there had been no lapse on the prosecution’s part.

She said the forensic report was the only outstanding document and was expected to take another four to five weeks to complete.

She also pointed out that less than a year had passed since the incident in May.

On the CCTV footage, Adiba said the recordings were still being examined to rule out any possibility of tampering.

Regarding Lai’s representation, she said the Attorney-General’s Chambers had yet to make a decision.

In dismissing the DNAA application, judge Noor Aini Yusof gave the prosecution one final opportunity to obtain the forensic report.

The court fixed Jan 5 next year for a further mention, with trial dates to be set if the outstanding reports were still unavailable.

All the accused were present in the dock.

They pleaded not guilty to voluntarily causing grievous hurt to businessman Andrew Teh, 47, using dangerous weapons at Restoran Hing Kee Bakuteh in Jalan Kepong at 2am on May 7.

The attack allegedly stemmed from an incident in which Teh was accused of staring at a man believed to be intoxicated while dining at the restaurant.

Teh was punched, kicked and struck with various objects, including chairs and a kettle, before managing to escape.