Man who smashed luxury condo sought retribution, not repairs, High Court rules

KUALA LUMPUR: A 68-year-old man who smashed marble tiles with a sledgehammer during a confrontation at a luxury condominium in Jalan Ampang was seeking retribution rather than attempting to resolve defects, the High Court ruled.

Judicial Commissioner Nixon Kennedy Kumbong said Tan Song Kwan’s actions at The Residences, a luxury serviced apartment developed by Tropicana Corporation Bhd, were premeditated and intended to damage the developer’s reputation.

“This is not the language of a person seeking rectification; it is the language of a person seeking retribution,” he said in his written judgment, recently uploaded to the judiciary’s website.

On Oct 15, the High Court ordered Tan to pay RM300,000 in general and aggravated damages to Tropicana Corporation Bhd and its subsidiary, Tropicana Residences Sdn Bhd, after allowing their defamation suit.

Nixon said Tan had prepared for the confrontation with the developer’s representatives by bringing a sledgehammer, protective goggles, gloves and a helmet to the unit on April 10, 2019.

He said Tan had also directed how the confrontation should be recorded, including when filming should begin and end, before the videos were widely circulated on social media.

“His conduct was not aimed at communicating a grievance to persons with a corresponding interest; it was aimed at generating maximum reputational harm.”

He added that the apartment, purchased by Tan’s sister, Tan Ching Bee, had initially been the subject of a complaint involving only four issues concerning marble tiles.

However, Tan later made broader allegations about defects involving furniture, fittings and other parts of the unit, although these were not raised in the original complaint.

Nixon said the developer had arranged for a marble specialist to attend the meeting and explain the characteristics of natural marble, but Tan refused to let him speak.

Instead, Tan sprayed red paint on furniture, smashed a glass dining table and repeatedly struck the marble tiles with a sledgehammer.

Nixon said Tan’s allegations of widespread defects were unsupported by the documents and contradicted by evidence presented during the trial.

He said Tan had also threatened to destroy Tropicana’s reputation locally and internationally, including by publicising the dispute through his contacts in Hong Kong, China, Taiwan and Singapore.

“I will make it a mission in my life to screw your Tropicana reputation down the drain,” Tan said during the confrontation.

The judge said the remarks went beyond complaints about poor workmanship and amounted to serious allegations of dishonesty, incompetence and commercial unreliability against the companies.

Nine video clips of the incident went viral on social media and received mainstream media coverage.

In assessing damages, Nixon said the premeditated confrontation, widespread circulation of the videos and threats to damage the companies’ reputation justified a substantial award.

However, the absence of proven financial losses and the plaintiffs’ status as corporate entities prevented a higher award.

The court also awarded RM50,000 in costs and imposed annual interest of five per cent on the damages, but dismissed the companies’ claim for exemplary damages.