The first thing you saw on Amazon Prime’s streaming site Thursday was Nicolas Cage’s face enlarged by prosthetics, adorned with fake eyebrows, and topped off by a bad hairpiece – unlike the believable ones he wears in real life – promising a John Madden biopic of a bigger-than-life figure.
That’s what “Madden” was supposed to be.
It was billed as the story of a coach-turned-broadcaster-turned-EA video game maven who touched generations of NFL fans and affected the game very much for the better.
JOHN MADDEN ROLE PUSHES NICOLAS CAGE TO DRAMATIC PHYSICAL TRANSFORMATION WITH ‘BRUTAL’ DIET, PROSTHETICS
But the reality of this 110-minute feature is we come away understanding the film would have been better done as an Al Davis bio, because Christian Bale’s portrayal of the since-deceased Oakland and Los Angeles Raiders owner was magnificent on every level while Cage was simply the wrong guy to play the great coach.
Quick aside that will cause some disagreement: The casting director or producer or whoever picked Cage as Madden obviously never saw Frank Caliendo impersonate Madden.
THE CAST OF ‘MADDEN’ HITS THE RED CARPET TO TALK ABOUT WHETHER THEY’VE CHOWED DOWN ON TURDUCKEN
Caliendo would have been an inspired choice to play the coach. And, yes, the height would have been a challenge, but we could have more easily forgiven elevator shoes than Cage sleepwalking through Madden as himself – with little effort to sound or act like the guy a generation of NFL fans watched broadcast games every season for decades.
The Rock (1996) and Family Man (2000) made Cage a generational star. But, sadly, Cage being one hundred percent Cage ruined this one for me.
It was easier buying former Seahawks running back Marshawn Lynch in his role as an EA Sports computer geek than Cage as Madden.
Not even Sienna Miller forcing us to watch her as Carol Davis because, well, Sienna Miller must be seen, or the football shots that were believable enough, or the nostalgic soundtrack, or Bale’s outstanding performance could save this movie.
The football scenes, by the way, were cool in an odd sense. It was like watching NFL Films on 1970s hallucinogens.
I definitely bought in to Bale’s work as Davis. The Oscar winner perfectly captured Davis in all his rebellious genius.
There were shots in which I actually believed I was watching Davis. Bale totally nailed the owner’s Brooklyn accent, spiced with a bit of Southern inflection.
True story: The first time I met Al Davis was in the early 1990s at an NFL spring meeting in Orlando.
I was in the bathroom using one of the urinals when Davis, wearing white pants, white shoes, a white Raiders jacket, and silver-rimmed dark sunglasses, walked up to the adjacent wall fixture, looked over, and asked my name.
Then he asked who I worked for. And then he told me he couldn’t wait to get “these damn meetings over with.”
Afterward, when we’d both washed our hands, he shook my hand and actually said, “Good luck, kid. Just win, baby.”
The man was a caricature of himself in real life and it was wonderful.
THE CRAIG CARTON SHOW–UNFILTERED, UNAPOLOGETIC AND UNMISSABLE. !
One of the comical scenes in Madden happens during an offseason meeting between the coach and Davis in the late 1970s.
I just about fell out of my seat when Davis introduces his young son Mark Davis to Madden because the red-headed bowl cut the young Davis is wearing is just a slightly earlier version of his latter-day bowl cut he still wears as the current Raiders owner.
When this movie is over, you’re left asking yourself whether you just saw a documentary or a drama or a comedy. Then you realize the film is none of the three. Because it fails at all three.
A friend of a friend who saw the movie on its first day put it this way:
“Just watched Madden. It is preposterously awful … and yet I sort of loved it.”
Well, that first part is accurate.
