‘No stepping up: Harimau Malaya’s fringe players fail Zhaoqing audition

KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia’s two-match tour of Zhaoqing was meant to expand the national team’s selection pool, but instead exposed the shortcomings of domestic league players when given the chance to step up.

With Johor Darul Ta’zim (JDT) regulars and six injured Selangor players unavailable, Harimau Malaya interim coach Tan Cheng Hoe turned to fringe players and non-regulars during last Saturday’s 2-0 defeat to China and Tuesday’s 2-1 win over Yemen.

Rather than giving Cheng Hoe more options ahead of next year’s Asian Cup and World Cup qualifiers, the tour highlighted a worrying gap in tempo, composure and adaptability between locally based players and their overseas counterparts.

Football observer Dr Zulakbal Abdul Karim said the difference was clear in how the two groups handled the demands of international football.

“I felt this was an opportunity for other players in the pool because we didn’t have the players from JDT and Selangor,” he said.

“However, the players in the M-League struggled with adapting to the international level demands compared to the players based abroad. This is adaptive intelligence or adaptability.

“The local boys were slow, got overwhelmed and there was a clear difference from the composure shown by the players based abroad.”

The contrast was sharpest in Scotland-based Richard Chin and Cyprus-based Fergus Tierney, who made stronger impressions than several established domestic players.

Richard, 24, brought urgency off the bench against China before scoring twice against Yemen.

Tierney offered physical presence and movement against China before being sent off in the closing stages.

“Tierney and Richard, who are younger than the established players in the M-League, showed how it’s done,” Zulakbal said.

Veteran winger Safawi Rasid’s return home because of a family matter further depleted the squad, placing greater responsibility on the remaining players.

Kuching City quartet Haziq Nadzli, Rodney Celvin, Ryan Lambert and Ramadhan Saifullah struggled to impose themselves against China.

Rodney was substituted at half-time after losing his marker for China’s second goal, while Ramadhan offered little attacking threat.

Defender Dominic Tan also had a difficult outing against China before missing the Yemen match with a muscle complaint, while standby call-ups Syafiq Ahmad and Danial Amier Norhisham failed to break into the starting line-up.

Terengganu players offered some encouragement.

Safwan Mazlan assisted Malaysia’s opening goal against Yemen, while Ubaidullah Shamsul and Haziq Kutty Abba showed promise during the tour.

For Zulakbal, however, the larger concern is the competitiveness of the domestic top flight and its ability to prepare players for international football.

“This is why the competitiveness level of the M-League needs to be improved,” the AFC elite instructor said.

“We need to have a competitive league domestically to push the players’ quality as well as exposing our players to international matches.

“The Malaysian Football League (MFL) and the FA of Malaysia (FAM) need to look at this closely. Our M-League is not really improving our players.

“We have been relying on naturalised players for the national team, and it looks like that will continue if our local players’ quality doesn’t improve.”

While the return of JDT and Selangor regulars will strengthen the squad, the Zhaoqing tour has raised questions over whether domestic fringe players can provide adequate depth when key players are unavailable.

“When the key players are not available for the national team, it is supposed to be an opportunity for the fringe players to stake a claim,” Zulakbal said.

“We were supposed to extend the pool of players in the absence of JDT and Selangor players, but it looks like we will have to depend on the regulars when they are back with the national team.”