In 1789, angry French citizens didn’t have Facebook, Instagram or TikTok to complain about the cost of living. They had pitchforks. And torches.
When bread prices became unbearable, thousands of women marched on the Palace of Versailles, demanding answers from King Louis XVI. They weren’t marching because the stock market was down.
They were marching because they couldn’t afford to feed their families.
GORDON SONDLAND: FRANCE IS BURNING, EUROPE’S BROKE, AND THE REVOLUTION IT REALLY NEEDS ISN’T VIOLENT
More than 230 years later, France is once again witnessing angry crowds in the streets. Italy has seen tens of thousands of workers and students protesting over wages, housing and living costs.
The circumstances are different. The frustration sounds remarkably familiar. People are working, collecting paychecks and wondering why they still can’t afford their lives.
MELONI CONDEMNS ‘GANGS OF THUGS’ AFTER PROTESTS TURNED VIOLENT ACROSS ITALY
And America had better pay attention.
Politicians love talking about economic growth, unemployment rates and inflation statistics. But here’s a little secret. Most Americans don’t wake up in the morning wondering what happened to GDP.
They wonder whether they can afford groceries, pay the electric bill and make their mortgage payment. And there’s an enormous difference between what economists call a healthy economy and what families experience at their kitchen tables.
MEHEK COOKE: REPUBLICANS FAILED THE AFFORDABILITY TEST. THIS IS HOW TO WIN VOTERS BACK
Inflation might fall from 8% to 3%. Wonderful. That doesn’t mean your $200 grocery bill goes back to $150. It means prices are generally rising more slowly. Your paycheck may have increased, but so have your insurance premiums, property taxes, utilities and rent.
The result? You can earn more money and still feel poorer.
EJ ANTONI: OVERSEAS WARS PUT AFFORDABILITY ON HOLD, BUT THAT’S ONLY TEMPORARY
France has experienced protests over living costs, public services and government finances. Italy has seen workers and students march over wages, housing affordability and their economic futures. Not every protest is about household bills, and most demonstrators aren’t rioters.
THOUSANDS FLOOD BRUSSELS STREETS AS ANTI-AUSTERITY PROTESTS ERUPT INTO CLASHES WITH POLICE
But the financial frustration deserves attention.
When people believe working hard no longer guarantees a reasonable standard of living, something changes. They stop believing the economic promises. They stop trusting the statistics.
DEMOCRATS SAY THEY’LL MAKE LIFE AFFORDABLE. YOUR WALLET MAY DISAGREE
And eventually, some take their anger into the streets.
Financial stress doesn’t disappear just because a government says inflation is under control.
AMERICANS SAY THEY’RE BROKE. SO WHY CAN’T THEY STOP SPENDING SO MUCH?
Think about the financial pressure facing an American family today. A young couple wants to buy their first home but can’t save a down payment fast enough to keep up with housing costs. Parents earn decent salaries but struggle with childcare, groceries, the cost of college and health insurance. Retirees on fixed incomes watch property taxes and insurance premiums eat into their savings and Social Security checks.
Meanwhile, credit cards become the emergency fund. Buy now, pay later becomes the family budgeting strategy. And everyone wonders why they feel financially exhausted.
Here’s the problem.
You can’t build long-term financial stability when every paycheck is already spoken for.
France’s fiscal troubles illustrate another uncomfortable reality. When governments accumulate enormous debt, interest payments compete with spending on services and other priorities.
America has now crossed $40 trillion in federal debt.
That doesn’t mean the United States is about to experience the French Revolution. But it does mean Washington has less room to respond to future economic shocks without difficult decisions about borrowing, taxes and spending. And households ultimately live with the consequences of those decisions.
Here’s what I’d like every politician in America to answer. After a family pays for housing, food, transportation, healthcare and utilities, how much money is actually left?
Not how much their wages increased on paper. Not whether inflation came down two percentage points. How much is left?
Because that remaining money determines whether families can save, invest, take a vacation or handle an emergency without going into debt.
If we want to improve affordability, we need more housing, stronger opportunities for wage growth, competitive markets and fiscal discipline. And families need to understand where their money is going before debt becomes their only option.
In 1789, the French marched on Versailles demanding bread. Today, families across Europe are demanding economic security. Americans are asking many of the same questions.
FOX NEWS OPINION
The lesson of history isn’t that every financial crisis ends with pitchforks and torches. It’s that when ordinary people can no longer afford ordinary lives, their frustration doesn’t stay at the kitchen table forever.
Washington should pay attention before the streets start delivering the economic report.
CLICK HERE TO READ MORE FROM TED JENKIN