The Spin | Sandpapergate’s ‘war of the ghosts’ highlights perils of relying on recall

One of Pat Cummins or Usman Khawaja must be lying about Cape Town? Not so, says a professor of memory

In 1932, the English psychologist Frederic Bartlett used cricket as a metaphor for memory. “When I make the stroke I do not, as a matter of fact, produce something absolutely new and I never merely repeat something old” he wrote in his landmark book Remembering: A Study in Experimental and Social Psychology.

Bartlett posited that remembering the past is just like playing a stroke, a cover drive say, in cricket. You can never repeat the stroke exactly, so like a fingerprint or snowflake, no two cover drives are exactly the same, even when played by the same person. Each cover drive is “manufactured” afresh in the new circumstances, the “schemata of the moment and their interrelations”.