Toddler’s murder culmination of sustained brutality by stepfather, says judge

KUALA LUMPUR: The murder of a two-year-old girl was not an isolated act of violence but the culmination of sustained physical abuse by her stepfather, the Alor Setar High Court ruled.

Judge Dr Mohammad Johan Lee said the toddler, Siti Nurlyana Humaira Muhammad Shahrul Nizam, was a defenceless child who had placed her complete trust in Muhammad Khairul Amirul Zainol.

Instead of protecting her, the 26-year-old accused subjected her to repeated abuse that eventually led to her death on April 21, 2022.

“The deceased was a defenceless toddler aged two years and seven months who stood in a relationship of complete dependency and trust toward the accused as her stepfather.

“Crucially, the post-mortem findings established that the fatal gastric rupture was not an isolated lapse of restraint, but the culmination of sustained physical brutality inflicted upon a helpless child,” he said.

The judge made the observations in his 57-page written grounds of judgment dated today, explaining his decision to convict Khairul of murdering his stepdaughter.

Khairul was sentenced to 35 years in prison and 15 strokes of the rotan on Sept 23 after being found guilty under Section 302 of the Penal Code.

Johan said the post-mortem examination revealed evidence of repeated abuse, including a healing fracture of the child’s left lower leg, estimated to be three to five weeks old.

Other injuries included multiple bruises, wounds on her scalp and face, injuries to her mouth and genital area, and torn earlobes which had been stitched at home using a sewing needle and thread.

The judge said the fatal injury was a two-centimetre tear in the child’s stomach wall caused by severe blunt force trauma.

The injury caused stomach contents to leak into her abdominal cavity, resulting in severe inflammation, toxic shock and death.

Forensic pathologist Dr Muhamad Yazid Yahya testified that such an injury required substantial force, such as a heavy punch, violent kick or strong crushing pressure.

The court heard that the toddler was left in Khairul’s care when her mother went to a Ramadan bazaar on April 20, 2022.

She was initially healthy but appeared weak and developed abdominal discomfort after her mother returned.

Her condition deteriorated the following day, leaving her unable to walk properly and suffering from vomiting and abdominal swelling.

Despite repeated requests to take the child to hospital, Khairul refused and instead applied medicated oil and massaged her stomach.

The toddler eventually collapsed and was pronounced dead at Jitra Hospital at 7pm on April 21.

Johan said the medical evidence established that the fatal injury had occurred about a day before her death, when she was under Khairul’s exclusive care.

He rejected the defence’s suggestions that the injury could have resulted from an accidental fall, resuscitation efforts or blows from a plastic clothes hanger.

“Domestic walls cannot serve as a sanctuary for impunity where an infant suffers fatal, non-accidental internal trauma in the sole custody of an adult caretaker,” he added.