Voter-roll deletions leave some Indian Muslims facing detention, deportation

WHEN Sahida Fakir stepped out of her Mumbai home on July 19 to buy vegetables, she told her son she would be back in minutes.

More than three months later, the 38-year-old is living in a Bangladeshi village, separated from her husband and two sons.

Fakir said plainclothes officers detained her, seized her phone, which she said contained copies of identity documents, and forced her across the border.

Court filings show the officials belonged to the Mumbai police crime branch.

“Someone grabbed my hand from behind and ordered me to get into the vehicle,” Fakir told Reuters in Satkhira, Bangladesh.

Fakir is among 10 families that Reuters interviewed whose relatives were detained, deported or questioned over their citizenship after being dropped from India’s revised electoral rolls.

All had Indian identity or family documents while relatives, including parents and siblings, remain on the voter lists.

The cases show how India’s sweeping voter-roll revision has become entangled with a separate drive to identify and expel suspected illegal immigrants, even though removal from the rolls does not itself establish that someone is a foreigner.

The voter list revision struck 130 million names nationwide in the largest deletion of voters in India’s history.

Data shows the omissions disproportionately affect Muslims, India’s largest minority, who have faced what rights groups describe as exclusionary policies and rising discrimination since Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) took power in 2014.

The revision sparked massive protests and accusations that the BJP was reshaping the electorate in its favour.

In West Bengal, where it has run furthest, around nine million names were cut ahead of state elections earlier this year.

Muslims made up about 70 per cent of the 2.7 million names deleted after a closer review, despite being 27 per cent of the population, according to the Kolkata-based Sabar Institute.

The BJP emerged victorious in those polls and took control of the state for the first time.

“We cannot deny the anti-incumbency factor, but the voter deletions played a big role in determining West Bengal election results,” the institute’s founder, Sabir Ahamed, said.

Fakir said she was pushed into Bangladesh at 1am from an unmanned, unfenced stretch of the border.

Now her husband, Jumman, is fighting her case in court, alongside millions of challenges to West Bengal’s voter-roll revision.

Family records reviewed by Reuters show Fakir’s parents and grandparents were registered voters in Swarupnagar, West Bengal, from India’s first national election in 1952.

Their names also appeared on the 2002-2003 rolls, a benchmark in the latest revision for determining who could remain without submitting additional documents.

Fakir herself has appeared on West Bengal’s electoral rolls since at least 2008, according to her voter ID seen by Reuters.

Mumbai’s Foreigners Regional Registration Office told the Calcutta High Court that Fakir produced a Bangladeshi birth certificate during an inquiry and failed to produce “valid or credible documentary evidence” establishing Indian citizenship.

Fakir disputed that, saying authorities seized her phone and gave her no opportunity to show copies of documents stored on it.

Indian law does not require citizens to carry valid identification at all times.

In another petition before the Calcutta High Court, utensil hawker Nasiruddin Sheikh and four others said they were detained after their names were
removed from the rolls, even though appeals against deletion were pending before special tribunals.

Sheikh said police detained him and 22 others while he was working hundreds of kilometres from home in Chhattisgarh.

Nineteen people were released when authorities found their names on revised rolls. Sheikh and three others whose names did not appear remained in custody for 32 days.

“A policeman told me, ‘your name is not in the voter list. You are a Bangladeshi’,” Sheikh said.

He was released with the others the night before their court hearing.

At a holding centre for suspected foreign migrants in Murshidabad, Reuters reporters saw clothes hanging inside and people peering from windows.

“There are millions of cases against deletion of names from voter list and people are waiting for justice,” human rights activist Kirity Roy said.

“The tribunals are slow. We are hopeless with what is going on.”


The writers are from Reuters


Discover more from UM LEGACY PRESS LTD

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.