KUALA LUMPUR: Wan Ahmad Fayhsal Wan Ahmad Kamal (PN-Machang) has questioned whether the leaching technique used at a rare earth mine in Gua Musang is safe, and whether the authorities have the expertise to assess it.
During the Dewan Rakyat question-and-answer session today, Wan Fayhsal asked whether the technology used at the mine was safe and whether the ministry and Department of Environment (DOE) had the technical expertise to assess its suitability.
He said the government had yet to provide sufficient information to the public about the technique, leaving questions about its safety and effectiveness.
“Does the ministry or the Department of Environment have the capability and expertise to assess the technology’s suitability?
“I feel this is something new, and much of the information remains opaque. We do not know the actual status of the technology,” he said.
Wan Fayhsal said both sides of the House shared the same aspiration to develop the country’s rare earth resources.
“I believe we do not differ in our views on developing rare earth resources.
“In fact, we are confident that if we switch places after the general election, we will do more for the country in this matter,” he said.
In response, Deputy Natural Resources and Environmental Sustainability Minister Syed Ibrahim Syed Noh said the project was a joint venture between French company Carester and Malaco Mining, with the necessary approvals granted following assessments to ensure environmental protection.
This includes an environmental impact assessment (EIA).
“In short, we do not take this lightly. We will monitor water quality, waste management and the rehabilitation of mining areas, and enforcement action will be taken against any violators,” he said.
On the broader mining policy, Syed Ibrahim said mining remained prohibited in permanent forest reserves, protected areas and environmentally sensitive areas.
“However, we know there is new technology and studies have been done.
“That will continue, to look at the feasibility of activities also taking place in permanent forest reserves,” he said.
He said the moratorium on raw rare earth exports, in force since Jan 1, 2024, would be maintained.
However, limited and conditional exports for research and development, as well as processing purposes, could be considered under guidelines issued on Oct 1.
Syed Ibrahim added that the policy did not need to be tabled in parliament but could instead be presented to a special select committee for briefing.
“We do not want the rare earth industry development policy to be merely a mining policy,” he said.
Earlier this year, Carester announced plans to develop a rare earth separation plant through a 10-year joint venture with Malaco Mining, which includes the transfer of processing technology to Malaysia.
