KUALA LUMPUR: Barisan Nasional has demanded that the government disclose the formula, valuation basis and approval minutes behind the reduction of the Kuala Lumpur and Selangor Chinese Assembly Hall (KLSCAH) land premium from RM4.67 million to RM1,000.
Manndzri Nasib (BN-Tenggara) said the substantial reduction for the renewal of the 99-year lease raised questions about transparency, governance and public revenue management.
“Do not hide behind discretionary powers. The ministry must disclose the circulars, official calculation formula and valuation basis used to reduce the premium from RM4.67 million to RM1,000 following the change in land use from commercial to institutional,” he said at a press conference in parliament today.
Previously, Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department (Federal Territories) Hannah Yeoh said the RM1,000 premium was imposed after KLSCAH agreed to reclassify the land for institutional use, giving up its potential for commercial development such as condominiums or shopping malls.
Yeoh said the 103-year-old building was gazetted as a heritage building in 2007.
Manndzri said BN recognised the Chinese community’s contribution to preserving KLSCAH as a national heritage site but maintained that its heritage and institutional status should not exempt the land premium assessment from scrutiny.
He said the site’s original valuation stood at RM4.67 million despite the building’s heritage status.
“Such technical justifications cannot be used as a shield to deflect broader questions about governance,” he said.
He also questioned the potential loss of government revenue, saying the foregone premium could have been used to upgrade People’s Housing Project facilities, assist the B40 group or fund flood mitigation projects in Kuala Lumpur.
Manndzri further urged the government to guarantee that the building would not be used for profit-making commercial rental activities.
He also proposed a clause allowing the government to recover the land’s market value if the stipulated land-use conditions were breached.
BN also sought clarification on whether the same nominal premium would apply to charitable organisations, places of worship and other ethnic heritage bodies in the Federal Territories under similar circumstances.
Manndzri questioned the decision to grant a 99-year lease when eight years remained on the original lease, and called for clarification on the land-use conditions and compliance monitoring mechanisms.
He said the ministry should also explain how the land was deemed to have no commercial development value following its reclassification as institutional land, and how the restrictions were factored into the RM1,000 premium assessment.
“BN will not compromise on the integrity of national assets and revenue management. The government cannot simply chant slogans about good governance but fail to practise them when faced with decisions that create perceptions of favouritism.
“The minister responsible must answer all these questions comprehensively and be prepared to explain the matter in the Dewan Rakyat.
“We demand transparent and consistent valuations for all institutions in similar circumstances,” he said.
