Court allows partial challenge over Kluang council’s stray dog SOPs

PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal today granted leave to the Kluang Animal Protection Association to pursue a judicial review challenging the Kluang Municipal Council’s (MPK) handling of stray dogs.

A three-member bench comprising Justices Datuk Dr Shahnaz Sulaiman, Datuk Amarjeet Singh and Alice Loke Yee Ching granted leave for two remedies sought by the association: a certiorari order and declaratory reliefs.

However, the court declined to grant leave for other remedies sought, namely a mandamus order, damages and a prohibitory order.

Delivering the unanimous decision, Justice Shahnaz said there was an arguable case for certiorari and declaratory relief, which ought to be ventilated at the substantive hearing.

“We allow in part this appeal. We grant leave for the relief of certiorari and declaration to proceed at the substantive stage,” said Shahnaz.

Shahnaz also said the association’s judicial review application, filed on May 7 last year, had been submitted within the prescribed time limit.

The panel remitted the case to the Johor Baru High Court for the substantive application to be heard by a different judge or judicial commissioner. Case management was fixed for Nov 24.

The association had filed the judicial review against MPK and its president, seeking declarations that the council had breached the Housing and Local Government Ministry secretary-general’s standard operating procedures (SOPs) on capturing and disposing of stray dogs in the municipality.

MPK denied allegations of mistreatment, maintaining that the dogs were disposed of in accordance with the SOPs.

On July 21 last year, the High Court dismissed the association’s application for leave to commence judicial review proceedings.

At today’s proceedings, lawyers Gavin Jayapal and Parveena Kaur represented the association while Senior Federal Counsel Suhana Sabil appeared for the Attorney-General. – BERNAMA