Dewan Rakyat row erupts over deputy speaker’s move to join debate

KUALA LUMPUR: A row broke out in the Dewan Rakyat today after Deputy Speaker Datuk Seri Dr Ramli Mohd Nor left the Speaker’s chair to take part in the committee-stage debate on the Works Ministry’s Budget 2027 allocation.

Ramli, who was presiding over the sitting, insisted that he had not abdicated his responsibilities.

“I did not abdicate my responsibility as Deputy Speaker.

“I only moved seats. I still chair the Dewan. That is very clear, and the interpretation of anything that happens in this Dewan remains with me. That is my decision,” he said.

Ramli (BN-Cameron Highlands) had spoken from another seat in his capacity as a member of parliament to question why letters of acceptance for several road projects had been deferred, including two in Pahang.

The projects were the 34km Pos Sendrut-Lipis road, estimated to cost RM320 million, and a RM90 million road linking Pos Selenjang to Pos Itom.

“What I want to know is who gave this instruction and what is the reason,” he said, adding that most of the affected projects were in BN and PN constituencies.

After Ramli returned to the chair, Datuk Ngeh Koo Ham (PH-Beruas) raised a point of order.

“I wish to record my sadness and my objection so that this parliament will not become a mockery and a laughing stock, not only in Malaysia but around the world,” he said.

Ngeh said a Speaker or chairman must always preside over proceedings and called for the incident to be expunged from the Hansard.

Ramli cited Standing Order 99, which provides that the Speaker’s or Deputy Speaker’s interpretation of the standing orders is final and that failure to comply with them does not invalidate proceedings.

He added that the standing orders were silent on whether a presiding officer could speak from another seat in the House, and told MPs who disagreed to move a motion.

Ngeh countered that Standing Order 99 “does not allow us to have a dictator as Speaker or Deputy Speaker in this Dewan”.

Datuk Seri Dr Ronald Kiandee (PN-Beluran), a former Deputy Speaker, said Ramli should have appointed someone to take the chair under Standing Order 7(3) while he participated in the debate.

“The Speaker guides the House, meaning somebody has to be there. It is convention,” he said.

“The vacancy is something that should not have happened.”

Kurniawan Naim Moktar (BN-Kinabatangan) then invoked Standing Order 36(6), which deals with imputations of improper motives, and asked Ngeh to withdraw the word “dictator”.

Ramli said he would settle the matter there.

“What happened just now still does not invalidate or mean I abdicated as chairman during the period I chaired the sitting,” he said before proceedings resumed.


Discover more from UM LEGACY PRESS LTD

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.