Explainer: Understanding Penang’s RM24.6bil Perak water deal

GEORGE TOWN: Penang’s RM24.6 billion water supply agreement with Perak has sparked a dispute between Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow and his predecessor Lim Guan Eng over who bears the financial risks.

The 40-year Bulk Water Supply Agreement (BWSA), signed between the Penang Water Supply Corporation (PBAPP) and Perak’s Prasarana Air dan Irigasi Perak Sdn Bhd (PAIP), is intended to secure the state’s water supply from 2032 to 2072.

Why does Penang need the deal?

Penang’s existing surface water resources are projected to reach full capacity by 2030, while demand is expected to exceed 1,100 million litres per day (MLD) by 2032.

The state needs an additional source of water to meet future industrial and domestic demand.

Chow has defended the agreement on cost grounds, saying sourcing treated water from Perak over 40 years would be more economical than building a comparable seawater desalination plant.

Such a plant would cost more than RM25 billion over 20 years, he said.

How is the RM24.6 billion structured?

Under the Northern Perak Water Supply Scheme (NPWSS), PAIP — a consortium involving Perak state entities and Gamuda Bhd — will build a dedicated RM3 billion treatment plant to supply Penang with between 300 and 500 MLD of treated water.

Penang will not have to fund the construction upfront.

The RM24.6 billion commitment comprises two charges:

Capacity charge (RM8.4 billion): PBAPP will pay RM210 million annually for 40 years to cover construction, financing, maintenance and asset upgrades.

Supply charge (RM16.2 billion): A variable charge based on the volume of treated water delivered to Penang at the required quality standards.

What is Lim Guan Eng’s criticism?

Despite securing nearly 98 per cent shareholder approval at PBA Holdings Bhd’s (PBAHB) extraordinary general meeting on Nov 12, the agreement’s payment terms have drawn criticism from Lim, who is Bagan MP and Air Putih assemblyman.

Lim’s main objections are:

Payments even without water supply: Lim, echoing written objections by five independent PBAHB directors, said PBAPP would have to pay RM210 million annually even if Perak supplied less than the contracted minimum of 300 MLD or delivered no water because of drought or domestic water needs.

Termination costs: Lim disputed claims that terminating the agreement over a failure to supply water would end Penang’s payment obligations. He said PBAPP would still have to pay a discounted lump sum based on the net present value (NPV) of the remaining capacity charges, amounting to more than RM1 billion.

Higher water tariffs: Lim warned that consumer bills could rise, with the bulk water tariff projected to increase from RM1.70 to RM7.21 per cubic metre over the agreement’s duration. He said further revisions could follow a review after 22 years, with PBAPP’s operating costs adding another RM1 per cubic metre.

Lack of transparency: Lim, who said he initiated the Perak water project during his tenure as chief minister, accused the state government of refusing to table the full agreement in the Penang State Legislative Assembly, citing non-disclosure clauses.