Landowners need not wait for disaster to seek court protection

KUALA LUMPUR: An adjoining property owner need not wait for a landslide or building collapse before seeking court protection against a neighbouring development that threatens their property, the High Court has ruled.

Judge Datuk Aliza Sulaiman, now a Court of Appeal judge, said preventive action was allowed where there was sufficient evidence of imminent danger and a risk of substantial damage that could not be adequately compensated.

She made the ruling in a dispute involving three Genting group companies and the developer of the proposed Genting Sky City project near the First World Hotel in Genting Highlands.

“These authorities do not require an adjoining occupier to wait until the threatened house or land actually falls or collapses,” Aliza said in her written grounds of judgment published by the Judiciary Department yesterday.

The suit was filed by Genting Highlands Bhd, Genting Malaysia Bhd and First World Hotels & Resorts Sdn Bhd against GM Aero Support Sdn Bhd, Sycal Bhd and four consultants involved in the proposed development.

The project, next to the First World Hotel complex, involved plans for several hotel and commercial buildings, including blocks of up to 56 storeys.

The Genting companies claimed that excavation, piling and slope-cutting works on the neighbouring land threatened the stability of their properties and surrounding roads.

The defendants denied the allegations, saying the development was safe and had obtained the necessary approvals.

Aliza said a court-appointed expert had found that the slopes needed strengthening before construction could proceed in any phase of the development.

She said the findings, together with evidence of water seepage, drainage conditions and the potential loss of support for occupied buildings and surrounding infrastructure, justified court intervention.

“Compensation after the feared instability would certainly not provide adequate protection,” she said.

The judge also rejected the defendants’ argument that the absence of a landslide or collapse during the legal proceedings showed that the development was safe.

She said construction activities had been restrained during that period and the absence of a disaster did not remove the risks identified by the experts.

Aliza said the danger was not speculative but supported by technical assessments of the slopes and proposed construction works.

However, she stressed that the injunction did not permanently prohibit all future development on the defendants’ land.

The court’s orders applied to the particular project and works examined during the trial.

The court also ordered the defendants to carry out specified backfilling works to restore disturbed sections at the foot of the slopes.

The work must begin within two months of service of the sealed judgment and be completed within six months of commencement.

The High Court awarded the Genting companies RM243,800 in general damages and RM2 million in legal costs after a 76-day trial involving extensive technical evidence.

However, it dismissed their claims for aggravated and exemplary damages and rejected the defendants’ counterclaim.

The defendants are appealing against the parts of the decision that went against them.


Discover more from UM LEGACY PRESS LTD

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.