KUALA LUMPUR: A Pakatan Harapan (PH) member of parliament has filed a motion seeking a Dewan Rakyat review of Deputy Speaker Datuk Dr Ramli Mohd Nor’s decision to leave the Speaker’s chair and take part in a debate while presiding over the sitting yesterday.
Chong Zhemin (PH-Kampar) said he submitted the notice under Standing Order 43 today, and that the Speaker’s Office had received it.
Ramli had left the chair while presiding over the committee-stage debate on the Works Ministry’s 2027 Budget yesterday before moving to his own seat to participate in the debate as the Cameron Highlands MP.
When Datuk Ngeh Koo Ham (PH-Beruas) stood up to ask who was chairing the meeting, Ramli replied that he was still presiding while taking part in the debate.
Chong said Standing Order 35(1) clearly stipulated that an MP could speak only after being called by the Chair.
“So I want to ask: who gave the member for Cameron Highlands his turn to speak when he began to debate? And if there is an objection to his speech, who will decide the objection?” he told a press conference in parliament today.
He said the standing orders also required a debater to address his speech to the Chair.
“If he acts as both member of parliament and chair at the same time, how can he address his speech to himself?” he said.
Chong said he had checked Commonwealth parliamentary conventions and found the situation to be unprecedented.
While agreeing with Ramli that the Standing Orders were silent on the matter, Chong said his motion sought a review of yesterday’s decision and the establishment of a clear procedure for similar situations in future.
Ngeh, who also spoke at the press conference, said the Standing Orders implied that a Speaker or chairman must preside over the sitting during the committee stage.
“The Malay proverb says, ‘Kalau sudah terang, tak perlulah suluh lagi’ (if it is already bright, there is no need to shine on it).
“That is why it does not need to be stated in writing in the Standing Orders,” he said.
He said the principles governing the chairing of a meeting went beyond the written Standing Orders, including the requirement for the chair to avoid conflicts of interest.
“As the deputy speaker listed himself yesterday as the first debater, putting himself first is itself an example of giving priority to his own interest over other debaters,” he said.
Ngeh said that when MPs questioned Ramli’s conduct yesterday, the deputy speaker repeatedly instructed them to sit down, invoking Standing Order 99 to maintain that his decision was final and could not be debated.
“This shows he breached the principles of chairing a meeting,” he said.
